or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 56 comments are related to an article called:

5 Best Defenders in PL Ever

Page 1 of 3

posted on 28/10/11

Vidic, Stam, Adams, Irwin,

cant decide the last

posted on 28/10/11

King

posted on 28/10/11

I think Rio defo has to be there, people are forgetting how good he acctually was.

posted on 28/10/11

Atouba and Titus "no means yes" Bramble

posted on 28/10/11

Stam, Adams, Neville, A Cole

posted on 28/10/11

Ian Harte was pretty damn good for Leeds
Albert for Newcastle

posted on 28/10/11

Might be a bit biased there
========================

You think?

comment by IAWT (U10012)

posted on 28/10/11

Desailly should be there too. At his prime, no one could pass him.
France remember Zidane for winning the world cup. But they forgot that Desailly kept a really solid defence.

comment by bcfc83 (U7811)

posted on 28/10/11

Ferdinand Coly!

posted on 28/10/11

1-Adams
2-Stam
3-Vidic
4-Campbell
5-Dessailly

posted on 28/10/11

ZZ looks about right

posted on 28/10/11

Arsenal had some top defenders back in the day..Dixon, Keowyn et al..Carragher deserves credit too..Neville has to be up there too..in his day he was immense..Rio in his prime was one of the best too..

posted on 28/10/11

in no particular order - stam, desailly, adams, campbell, hyypia.

posted on 28/10/11

hyypia was good too, desailly not for me though.

posted on 28/10/11

Carl Jenkinson?

posted on 28/10/11

what about Terry and Carvalho.

posted on 28/10/11

Adams
Vidic
Campbell
Desailly
Carvalho

comment by MU18 (U3143)

posted on 28/10/11

Agree that Carvalho should be up there, not so sure about Terry as much.

comment by Diggler (U4142)

posted on 28/10/11

Vidic
Stam
Desailly
Adams
Hyppia

posted on 28/10/11

Vermaelen

comment by Diggler (U4142)

posted on 28/10/11

Actually,

Vidic
Stam
Campbell
Desailly
Hyppia

posted on 28/10/11

Adams
Campbell
Vidic
Stam
Kompany (controversial i know but i think he's awesome)

posted on 28/10/11

Can't believe no one's mentioned Senderos

posted on 28/10/11

Cygan

posted on 28/10/11

Squillaci

Page 1 of 3

Sign in if you want to comment