or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 838 comments are related to an article called:

Defoe

Page 7 of 34

posted on 18/1/12

I take it you dont have a reply to my post then?
__________________________

You responded to my comment? Honestly didn't see it.

Be a gent and post it again can you?

posted on 18/1/12

CutMeAndIBleedRed

yet on ONE particular week, you decide to pick 3 and say it's out of them?!

============================

I've not said its out of 3, ive always said its out of just Arsenal & Chelsea.

It was you's who thought we should include Liverpool, and in turn include Newcastle.

Wrong again sweetcheeks.

posted on 18/1/12

"But instead of admitting it, you can always just keep arguing with us about it,"

Isn't that what we're here for - it's a discussion forum!!


"whilst throwing in the odd insult."

I haven't thrown a single insult - it isn't my style!

posted on 18/1/12

I've not said its out of 3, ive always said its out of just Arsenal & Chelsea.

Oh, fair enough cos that disproves my point - let me see, I said choosing 3 out of 4 is ridiculous i.e. all four have a chance and you reply with 'ha, i said 2 actually' - genius keep um coming!

posted on 18/1/12

I think I prefer the Suarez/Evra debates compared to reading what Spurs fans think they know about football.

That is how boring this thread is now.

posted on 18/1/12

TGF - I can sum up what Chicken knows about football:

posted on 18/1/12

johnsonsbaby,

I didnt accuse you personally of throwing the insults. I think you can probably work out which poster that comment related to.

Debating is fine but i sometimes get the feeling some posters simply argue out of stubbornness, rather than debating reasonably & giving valid points for their side.

Again, not a dig at you.

posted on 18/1/12

johnsonsbaby,

See what i mean?







The God Fowler

That is how boring this thread is now.

=================

So boring you still felt the need to post on it.



posted on 18/1/12

I don't suppose you were in front of a mirror when making you above points Chicken?

posted on 18/1/12

comment by CutMeAndIBleedRed (U7593)

posted 2 minutes ago

TGF - I can sum up what Chicken knows about football:
--------------

I have already told Chicken about 100 comments ago that he has proven he knows nothing by some of the comments he has made, but he keeps on writing drivel.

posted on 18/1/12

No matter how reasonable the points are put across you refuse to see how daft your theory is. Do you honestly believe the table will be the same in may as it is today?

posted on 18/1/12

"I didnt accuse you personally of throwing the insults."

Fair enough.

I'm of the opinion that anybody can go on any board they like - nobody 'owns' a board, if however one chooses to go on a rival board, don't complain about arguments!

posted on 18/1/12

Chicken

I posted to let you know that whatever rubbish you spouted i was supposed to reply to god knows how many comments ago, that i was not going to as it bores me now.

posted on 18/1/12

terentius1,

Can you elaborate on what you mean by "you above points Chicken"?

(And no i dont mean in terms f the typo error - just what points of mine you are referring to).

It just makes it easier to reply, thats all.

posted on 18/1/12

The God Fowler

So bored, you just keep coming back eh?

posted on 18/1/12

Chicken. I was referring to the stubbornness!

posted on 18/1/12

Can't believe this article is still going

posted on 18/1/12

Can't decide what to have for tea

posted on 18/1/12

terentius1,

Do you honestly believe the table will be the same in may as it is today?

===========================

It will not change dramatically. As I said, I cannot ever recall a team sitting in 7th in January make the Top 4 – not ever. Something else you all refuse to take into account.

I also cannot see Wigan winning the league.



johnsonsbaby,

I'm of the opinion that anybody can go on any board they like - nobody 'owns' a board, if however one chooses to go on a rival board, don't complain about arguments!

===========================

Sounds a bit childish to me.







The God Fowler ,

You’re like a fly to a lightbulb, you know you shouldn’t go near it but you just cant help yourself.




GazMan,

In short, Liverpool are still favourites for 4th, regardless of form, squads or league position.


posted on 18/1/12

"Sounds a bit childish to me. "


Well you would know

posted on 18/1/12

"In short, Liverpool are still favourites for 4th, regardless of form, squads or league position"

I've just read through the comments and no one's said we're favourites for 4th. We are in contention for 4th, there's a big difference. Unless you account for your magical cut off point that rules Arsenal in and us out .

Again using your logic. You are 5 points off City in 1st. Therefore all talk of Spurs challenging for the title should be ignored. After all 5 points is too much to overhaul in 17 games.

posted on 18/1/12

'In short, Liverpool are still favourites for 4th, regardless of form, squads or league position.'

You said it! FORM - LEAGUE POSITION - put those two together! You still haven't come up with a reasoned response regarding your 'theory' putting Liverpool squarely in contention LAST WEEK (i.e. the FORM part)!!!!

posted on 18/1/12

Fish & chips for me

posted on 18/1/12

red_man23

We are in contention for 4th, there's a big difference. Unless you account for your magical cut off point that rules Arsenal in and us out

======================

Its not a "magical" cut off point, its one based on common sense. As i said (for about the 5th time), i cannot recall any team sitting in 7th, in late January, ever making 4th spot. This would make your "contention" for 4th even more unlikely.

And i agreed that making 5pts up on City is also very unlikely, so i dont know what your point is there.

Do you realise you are just as close to Stoke in 8th as you are to 4th?



Lastly, when speaking about contenders for 4th place (in January) how far down the league do you think we should go? Do you think its realistic to include any team where it is mathematically possible, or just down as far as Liverpool - to keep this board happy?

posted on 18/1/12

'how far down the league do you think we should go?' how about as far as the team that was level on points LAST WEEK with one of your contenders - are you deliberately being this thick?!

Page 7 of 34

Sign in if you want to comment