Dave
He did get the injury then came back and the next month broke the curfew.
I don't think he ever played for them again.
Its not just that
Too many people on here with women's brains. They over exaggerate, over dramatise, overreact to any given situation.
i icant tell if your taking the pee thunder
I would say he's already better than Young.
comment by Thunderkiss_65_ (U2407)
posted 6 minutes ago
He looks formidable in the reserves when played through the middle too. I can only assume the club is saving him for the second half of the season.
............
I wonder who that was aimed at.
comment by Red Rob is a Paul Heyman Guy (U9808)
---------------
He done his ACL, he was sent back to United when it happened
Dunc
Yeah, it's precisely because he hasn't had the same football education as the other that I think he won't make it.
Most footballers go through academies and have a vast football 'education' if they are to succeed at a club like United. Now of course, he could be the exception to the rule but I personally don't see it.
There's looking poor in the first few weeks at a new club and there's looking as bad as Bebe did against Crawley in the game most of us seem to have forgotten.
He does look good in the reserves and obviously has more natural talent than you or I but I don't think it's enough to play ahead of someone like Young or Valencia who are out of form but even on a bad day must surely offer more than Bebe.
I hope i'm wrong because I have nothing against Bebe and it doesn't make any difference to my life if he makes it or not but I just can't see it.
Thunderkiss
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%A9b%C3%A9
Bebe suffered the injury on 9th August 2011 but came back from injury in March 2012. He was banished from the squad in April 2012
There's looking poor in the first few weeks at a new club and there's looking as bad as Bebe did against Crawley in the game most of us seem to have forgotten
---------
34 Lindegaard
06 Brown yellow card
20 Fabio Da Silva (Fletcher 69)
21 Rafael (Smalling 54)
22 O'Shea
08 Anderson (Rooney 46 yellow card)
16 Carrick
28 Gibson
14 Hernandez
26 Obertan
33 Tiago Bebe
that was the team that struggled against crawley, and everyone was P 1 s s poor, yet it is always easier to blame the new tramp that has just been signed than actually blame the internationals in the team that had been at the club for years... strange that
So you're writing him off because of one game?
Here's the team that played Arsenal a few weeks later
Van Der Saar
Brown
Evra
Smalling
Vidic
Fabio
Rafael
O'Shea
Gibson
Rooney
Hernandez
Not a huge difference other than at the back and Rooney for Bebe but considering the difference in class between Arsenal (their first team) and Crawley you can't blame the other people around Bebe.
Hell, he had Anderson in CM! Against Arsenal we had defenders!
Bebe wasn't just bad that game, he was awful and everyone on here at the time agreed but it's been forgotten.
He may have improved since then and good on him but he has to do it in the first team for me to believe he has a future at United. The fact he didn't even play in the league cup isn't a great sign.
There's looking poor in the first few weeks at a new club and there's looking as bad as Bebe did against Crawley in the game most of us seem to have forgotten.
*****************************
You forget every player on that day was useless too.
Your rubbish really it exhausting to counter.
Rob
Arsenal were worse than Crawley that day.
VC I'l answer you on here mate
It was actually an orange tie. Did look like a red one though from afar. Dont think he'l make the same mistake in future of wearing a shade so close to red
VC
Given that you've been watching football for many years do you think Bebe has a future at the club?
I think anything can happen in football but if you were a betting man?
Not a huge difference other than at the back and Rooney for Bebe but considering the difference in class between Arsenal (their first team) and Crawley you can't blame the other people around Bebe.
----------
sorry, but that is one of the most stupid comments i have seen on here when someone is actually being serious
you're saying, that because the team performed better against Arsenal, that the reason 10 players played sheite against crawley was because bebe was in the team
seriously rob, that is awful
comment by Mr Chelsea ✪ #SayNoToStability #IRWT #BringBackRDM (U3579)
posted 42 seconds ago
VC I'l answer you on here mate
It was actually an orange tie. Did look like a red one though from afar. Dont think he'l make the same mistake in future of wearing a shade so close to red
.............
I couldn't believe it when I saw it on your board.
Rafa sure knows how to make friends.
comment by Red Rob is a Paul Heyman Guy (U9808)
posted 1 minute ago
VC
Given that you've been watching football for many years do you think Bebe has a future at the club?
..................
No. But my opinion isn't based on one match.
I know mate but its only a tie.. I think he's getting a rough ride to be fair. Feel sorry for him
http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/03/07/article-0-03B3145A000005DC-875_468x345.jpg
Dunc
It wasn't just Crawley. It was Wolves too where he might just have been worse.
Look, I feel like i'm in some kind of bizzarro world where people have forgotten just how awful Bebe has been and think he is the answer to a temporary blip in the wingers form at the club.
This is one thing i'd be happy to be wrong over but only time will tell. If he really was that promising don't you think we would have played in the league cup? Even been on the bench?
VC
Fair enough but i'm not just basing my opinion on Crawley. It was just one example. I'm basing it on Wolves too.
I'd have more games to judge him on but he hasn't played many more. And isn't anywhere nearer to the match squad so we may never get the chance to judge him.
And based on this bizzarro world i'm sure people on here will say that Sir Alex never gave him a chance.
Against Wolves, he had been at the club for 2 months.
He didn't get any time to adapt, he was just thrown away.
If Kagawa wasn't showing any signs of his class already, would he be loaned out?
Wolves, the game where Bebe (a sub) was so bad he was subbed!
The point is though rob he's doing we'll for the reserves so he deserves a chance. You're the one constantly banging on about fairness when it comes to our keepers. Why does the same not go for Bebr?
Sign in if you want to comment
Wingers
Page 2 of 5
posted on 29/11/12
Dave
He did get the injury then came back and the next month broke the curfew.
I don't think he ever played for them again.
posted on 29/11/12
Its not just that
Too many people on here with women's brains. They over exaggerate, over dramatise, overreact to any given situation.
posted on 29/11/12
i icant tell if your taking the pee thunder
posted on 29/11/12
I would say he's already better than Young.
posted on 29/11/12
comment by Thunderkiss_65_ (U2407)
posted 6 minutes ago
He looks formidable in the reserves when played through the middle too. I can only assume the club is saving him for the second half of the season.
............
I wonder who that was aimed at.
posted on 29/11/12
comment by Red Rob is a Paul Heyman Guy (U9808)
---------------
He done his ACL, he was sent back to United when it happened
posted on 29/11/12
Dunc
Yeah, it's precisely because he hasn't had the same football education as the other that I think he won't make it.
Most footballers go through academies and have a vast football 'education' if they are to succeed at a club like United. Now of course, he could be the exception to the rule but I personally don't see it.
There's looking poor in the first few weeks at a new club and there's looking as bad as Bebe did against Crawley in the game most of us seem to have forgotten.
He does look good in the reserves and obviously has more natural talent than you or I but I don't think it's enough to play ahead of someone like Young or Valencia who are out of form but even on a bad day must surely offer more than Bebe.
I hope i'm wrong because I have nothing against Bebe and it doesn't make any difference to my life if he makes it or not but I just can't see it.
posted on 29/11/12
Thunderkiss
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%A9b%C3%A9
Bebe suffered the injury on 9th August 2011 but came back from injury in March 2012. He was banished from the squad in April 2012
posted on 29/11/12
There's looking poor in the first few weeks at a new club and there's looking as bad as Bebe did against Crawley in the game most of us seem to have forgotten
---------
34 Lindegaard
06 Brown yellow card
20 Fabio Da Silva (Fletcher 69)
21 Rafael (Smalling 54)
22 O'Shea
08 Anderson (Rooney 46 yellow card)
16 Carrick
28 Gibson
14 Hernandez
26 Obertan
33 Tiago Bebe
that was the team that struggled against crawley, and everyone was P 1 s s poor, yet it is always easier to blame the new tramp that has just been signed than actually blame the internationals in the team that had been at the club for years... strange that
posted on 29/11/12
So you're writing him off because of one game?
posted on 29/11/12
Here's the team that played Arsenal a few weeks later
Van Der Saar
Brown
Evra
Smalling
Vidic
Fabio
Rafael
O'Shea
Gibson
Rooney
Hernandez
Not a huge difference other than at the back and Rooney for Bebe but considering the difference in class between Arsenal (their first team) and Crawley you can't blame the other people around Bebe.
Hell, he had Anderson in CM! Against Arsenal we had defenders!
Bebe wasn't just bad that game, he was awful and everyone on here at the time agreed but it's been forgotten.
He may have improved since then and good on him but he has to do it in the first team for me to believe he has a future at United. The fact he didn't even play in the league cup isn't a great sign.
posted on 29/11/12
There's looking poor in the first few weeks at a new club and there's looking as bad as Bebe did against Crawley in the game most of us seem to have forgotten.
*****************************
You forget every player on that day was useless too.
Your rubbish really it exhausting to counter.
posted on 29/11/12
Rob
Arsenal were worse than Crawley that day.
posted on 29/11/12
VC I'l answer you on here mate
It was actually an orange tie. Did look like a red one though from afar. Dont think he'l make the same mistake in future of wearing a shade so close to red
posted on 29/11/12
VC
Given that you've been watching football for many years do you think Bebe has a future at the club?
I think anything can happen in football but if you were a betting man?
posted on 29/11/12
Not a huge difference other than at the back and Rooney for Bebe but considering the difference in class between Arsenal (their first team) and Crawley you can't blame the other people around Bebe.
----------
sorry, but that is one of the most stupid comments i have seen on here when someone is actually being serious
you're saying, that because the team performed better against Arsenal, that the reason 10 players played sheite against crawley was because bebe was in the team
seriously rob, that is awful
posted on 29/11/12
comment by Mr Chelsea ✪ #SayNoToStability #IRWT #BringBackRDM (U3579)
posted 42 seconds ago
VC I'l answer you on here mate
It was actually an orange tie. Did look like a red one though from afar. Dont think he'l make the same mistake in future of wearing a shade so close to red
.............
I couldn't believe it when I saw it on your board.
Rafa sure knows how to make friends.
posted on 29/11/12
comment by Red Rob is a Paul Heyman Guy (U9808)
posted 1 minute ago
VC
Given that you've been watching football for many years do you think Bebe has a future at the club?
..................
No. But my opinion isn't based on one match.
posted on 29/11/12
I know mate but its only a tie.. I think he's getting a rough ride to be fair. Feel sorry for him
posted on 29/11/12
http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/03/07/article-0-03B3145A000005DC-875_468x345.jpg
posted on 29/11/12
Dunc
It wasn't just Crawley. It was Wolves too where he might just have been worse.
Look, I feel like i'm in some kind of bizzarro world where people have forgotten just how awful Bebe has been and think he is the answer to a temporary blip in the wingers form at the club.
This is one thing i'd be happy to be wrong over but only time will tell. If he really was that promising don't you think we would have played in the league cup? Even been on the bench?
posted on 29/11/12
VC
Fair enough but i'm not just basing my opinion on Crawley. It was just one example. I'm basing it on Wolves too.
I'd have more games to judge him on but he hasn't played many more. And isn't anywhere nearer to the match squad so we may never get the chance to judge him.
And based on this bizzarro world i'm sure people on here will say that Sir Alex never gave him a chance.
posted on 29/11/12
Against Wolves, he had been at the club for 2 months.
He didn't get any time to adapt, he was just thrown away.
If Kagawa wasn't showing any signs of his class already, would he be loaned out?
posted on 29/11/12
Wolves, the game where Bebe (a sub) was so bad he was subbed!
posted on 29/11/12
The point is though rob he's doing we'll for the reserves so he deserves a chance. You're the one constantly banging on about fairness when it comes to our keepers. Why does the same not go for Bebr?
Page 2 of 5