Only in your world has he been "brilliant technically." You're living in Narnia mate.
.........................
Rooneys goal against West Ham last season, brilliant technicallY, as were the overhead kick against City, freekicks to numerous to list, havf volley against the geordies. Look it all up on youtube.
So is he or is he not better than RVN?
............
Better goal scorer, no, better all round player, yes.
I have already told you this.
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 12 minutes ago
Only in your world has he been "brilliant technically." You're living in Narnia mate.
.........................
Rooneys goal against West Ham last season, brilliant technicallY, as were the overhead kick against City, freekicks to numerous to list, havf volley against the geordies. Look it all up on youtube.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly
Technically, Rooney has been brilliant over the years
Scholay simply has a juvenile understanding of what being technically gifted means
It's one of the reasons I am fairly excited about James Wilson. Technically, as a finisher,he is brilliant
As strikers there really isn't. RVN had a better goal per game record in the prem, as all round players, IMO Henry was superior.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So the answer is Henry is a better player? I did not ask as strikers, I asked simply as players.
.................
I don't care what you asked for.
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something I was never arguing about between RVP and Rooney in the first place.
The beauty of reading the thread first instead of jumping in and getting it all wrong.
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 1 minute ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have no problem with that.
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 1 minute ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have no problem with that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That's that.
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something
---------------
haha yeah
He did the same with me about Shearer and failed
tbh, I'm not too sure why he wouldn't think Shearer has claims to have been the PL's greatest ever striker. Maybe he isn't old enough to have seen him play
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 6 minutes ago
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something I was never arguing about between RVP and Rooney in the first place.
The beauty of reading the thread first instead of jumping in and getting it all wrong.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm just tired of going back and forward, you talk a lot of nonsense. Everyone knows Henry is a much better player than RVN. You are there beating the bush around it. I have a world cup match to watch.
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something
---------------
haha yeah
He did the same with me about Shearer and failed
tbh, I'm not too sure why he wouldn't think Shearer has claims to have been the PL's greatest ever striker. Maybe he isn't old enough to have seen him play
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No I did not, i merely asked him who he thought was the better player. What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous. Jesus, can two people ever stop licking each others backsides so much. When you asked is python claim about RVP being twice better than rooney, said that claim is wrong. FFS, act your age.
I'm just tired of going back and forward, you talk a lot of nonsense.
........
I very rarely talf nonsense.
If you had read my earlier comments on this thread then you could have saved yourself a whole lot of trouble.
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 18 minutes ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
............
I don't really rate Rooney any higher than RVP.
I have always maintained that there is very little between them.
There are certain circumstances where if I had a choice between the two I would opt for RVP. That can also be said of Rooney.
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 18 minutes ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
............
I don't really rate Rooney any higher than RVP.
I have always maintained that there is very little between them.
There are certain circumstances where if I had a choice between the two I would opt for RVP. That can also be said of Rooney.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read this threat thoroughly, not once did i insinuate that you rated Rooney higher. Also, not once did I support the claim that RVP is twice the player Rooney is. My debate came solely from using stats to make a comparison of players. And that alone is the reason why I asked you about Henry and RVN. Maybe you should read things before just talking for the sake of it, we are all tired of it.
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 9 minutes ago
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because I can easily name 5 strikers who are better and more influential than him during their time in the prem. The guy played when the prem was more than 40 games a season
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 18 minutes ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
............
I don't really rate Rooney any higher than RVP.
I have always maintained that there is very little between them.
There are certain circumstances where if I had a choice between the two I would opt for RVP. That can also be said of Rooney.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read this threat thoroughly, not once did i insinuate that you rated Rooney higher. Also, not once did I support the claim that RVP is twice the player Rooney is. My debate came solely from using stats to make a comparison of players. And that alone is the reason why I asked you about Henry and RVN. Maybe you should read things before just talking for the sake of it, we are all tired of it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thread*
Scholay
man to man
Your opening gambit on the thread was juvenile and stupid
It didn't set you in the right light for a decent debate on the subject
Next time, don't join a thread by spouting silly drivel and you may get taken more seriously
I'll say again, as forwards in my opinion, there is very little in it
Rooney is more versatile
I read this threat thoroughly, not once did i insinuate that you rated Rooney higher.
...........
I am talking to Manc Python you cretin.
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 2 minutes ago
Scholay
man to man
Your opening gambit on the thread was juvenile and stupid
It didn't set you in the right light for a decent debate on the subject
Next time, don't join a thread by spouting silly drivel and you may get taken more seriously
I'll say again, as forwards in my opinion, there is very little in it
Rooney is more versatile
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two, we all know how you are if people are not beating to the tune of your drum. Man to man.....
RVP is way better than Rooney.
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 20 minutes ago
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
....................
God only knows.
He is way up there wityh the very best.
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two,
............
Then you have more than easilly accomplished that objective.
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 18 seconds ago
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two,
............
Then you have more than easilly accomplished that objective.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fine. I will go watch Ivory Coast and Columbia. Have a sambuca mate, fark me you need it.
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 9 minutes ago
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because I can easily name 5 strikers who are better and more influential than him during their time in the prem. The guy played when the prem was more than 40 games a season
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The number of games is irrelvent to how good a striker Shearer was
As a number 9, he was lethal
I would guess Shearer's goals to game ratio wasn't as good as say Henry but Shearer spent his career at Southampton Blackburn and Newcastle
Rooney is closing in on Sir Bobby Charton's United record but he is still a country mile away from Shearer's PL record
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 2 minutes ago
Scholay
man to man
Your opening gambit on the thread was juvenile and stupid
It didn't set you in the right light for a decent debate on the subject
Next time, don't join a thread by spouting silly drivel and you may get taken more seriously
I'll say again, as forwards in my opinion, there is very little in it
Rooney is more versatile
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two,
------------------------------------
Congratulations
You certainly achieved that objective
Sign in if you want to comment
RVP & Moyes
Page 8 of 9
6 | 7 | 8 | 9
posted on 19/6/14
Only in your world has he been "brilliant technically." You're living in Narnia mate.
.........................
Rooneys goal against West Ham last season, brilliant technicallY, as were the overhead kick against City, freekicks to numerous to list, havf volley against the geordies. Look it all up on youtube.
posted on 19/6/14
So is he or is he not better than RVN?
............
Better goal scorer, no, better all round player, yes.
I have already told you this.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 12 minutes ago
Only in your world has he been "brilliant technically." You're living in Narnia mate.
.........................
Rooneys goal against West Ham last season, brilliant technicallY, as were the overhead kick against City, freekicks to numerous to list, havf volley against the geordies. Look it all up on youtube.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Exactly
Technically, Rooney has been brilliant over the years
Scholay simply has a juvenile understanding of what being technically gifted means
It's one of the reasons I am fairly excited about James Wilson. Technically, as a finisher,he is brilliant
posted on 19/6/14
As strikers there really isn't. RVN had a better goal per game record in the prem, as all round players, IMO Henry was superior.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
So the answer is Henry is a better player? I did not ask as strikers, I asked simply as players.
.................
I don't care what you asked for.
posted on 19/6/14
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something I was never arguing about between RVP and Rooney in the first place.
The beauty of reading the thread first instead of jumping in and getting it all wrong.
posted on 19/6/14
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 1 minute ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have no problem with that.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 48 seconds ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 1 minute ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I have no problem with that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That's that.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something
---------------
haha yeah
He did the same with me about Shearer and failed
tbh, I'm not too sure why he wouldn't think Shearer has claims to have been the PL's greatest ever striker. Maybe he isn't old enough to have seen him play
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 6 minutes ago
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something I was never arguing about between RVP and Rooney in the first place.
The beauty of reading the thread first instead of jumping in and getting it all wrong.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm just tired of going back and forward, you talk a lot of nonsense. Everyone knows Henry is a much better player than RVN. You are there beating the bush around it. I have a world cup match to watch.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 minutes ago
I think Scholay has just realized that he was trying to back me into saying something
---------------
haha yeah
He did the same with me about Shearer and failed
tbh, I'm not too sure why he wouldn't think Shearer has claims to have been the PL's greatest ever striker. Maybe he isn't old enough to have seen him play
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No I did not, i merely asked him who he thought was the better player. What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous. Jesus, can two people ever stop licking each others backsides so much. When you asked is python claim about RVP being twice better than rooney, said that claim is wrong. FFS, act your age.
posted on 19/6/14
I'm just tired of going back and forward, you talk a lot of nonsense.
........
I very rarely talf nonsense.
If you had read my earlier comments on this thread then you could have saved yourself a whole lot of trouble.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 18 minutes ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
............
I don't really rate Rooney any higher than RVP.
I have always maintained that there is very little between them.
There are certain circumstances where if I had a choice between the two I would opt for RVP. That can also be said of Rooney.
posted on 19/6/14
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 18 minutes ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
............
I don't really rate Rooney any higher than RVP.
I have always maintained that there is very little between them.
There are certain circumstances where if I had a choice between the two I would opt for RVP. That can also be said of Rooney.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read this threat thoroughly, not once did i insinuate that you rated Rooney higher. Also, not once did I support the claim that RVP is twice the player Rooney is. My debate came solely from using stats to make a comparison of players. And that alone is the reason why I asked you about Henry and RVN. Maybe you should read things before just talking for the sake of it, we are all tired of it.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 9 minutes ago
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because I can easily name 5 strikers who are better and more influential than him during their time in the prem. The guy played when the prem was more than 40 games a season
posted on 19/6/14
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by Manc Python (U17527)
posted 18 minutes ago
I think gentlemen bottom line is macca and vc rate rooney higher and myself and scholay rate rvp higher.
end of
............
I don't really rate Rooney any higher than RVP.
I have always maintained that there is very little between them.
There are certain circumstances where if I had a choice between the two I would opt for RVP. That can also be said of Rooney.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I read this threat thoroughly, not once did i insinuate that you rated Rooney higher. Also, not once did I support the claim that RVP is twice the player Rooney is. My debate came solely from using stats to make a comparison of players. And that alone is the reason why I asked you about Henry and RVN. Maybe you should read things before just talking for the sake of it, we are all tired of it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
thread*
posted on 19/6/14
Scholay
man to man
Your opening gambit on the thread was juvenile and stupid
It didn't set you in the right light for a decent debate on the subject
Next time, don't join a thread by spouting silly drivel and you may get taken more seriously
I'll say again, as forwards in my opinion, there is very little in it
Rooney is more versatile
posted on 19/6/14
I read this threat thoroughly, not once did i insinuate that you rated Rooney higher.
...........
I am talking to Manc Python you cretin.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 2 minutes ago
Scholay
man to man
Your opening gambit on the thread was juvenile and stupid
It didn't set you in the right light for a decent debate on the subject
Next time, don't join a thread by spouting silly drivel and you may get taken more seriously
I'll say again, as forwards in my opinion, there is very little in it
Rooney is more versatile
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two, we all know how you are if people are not beating to the tune of your drum. Man to man.....
RVP is way better than Rooney.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 20 minutes ago
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
....................
God only knows.
He is way up there wityh the very best.
posted on 19/6/14
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two,
............
Then you have more than easilly accomplished that objective.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 18 seconds ago
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two,
............
Then you have more than easilly accomplished that objective.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fine. I will go watch Ivory Coast and Columbia. Have a sambuca mate, fark me you need it.
posted on 19/6/14
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 9 minutes ago
What did i try to do to you with Shearer, i thought the claim was ridiculous
-------------------
What is so ridiculous about Shearer having a claim to be the PL's greatest ever striker?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Because I can easily name 5 strikers who are better and more influential than him during their time in the prem. The guy played when the prem was more than 40 games a season
----------------------------------------------------------------------
The number of games is irrelvent to how good a striker Shearer was
As a number 9, he was lethal
I would guess Shearer's goals to game ratio wasn't as good as say Henry but Shearer spent his career at Southampton Blackburn and Newcastle
Rooney is closing in on Sir Bobby Charton's United record but he is still a country mile away from Shearer's PL record
posted on 19/6/14
comment by scholayScholes (U13961)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by UnitedRedMacca (U2024)
posted 2 minutes ago
Scholay
man to man
Your opening gambit on the thread was juvenile and stupid
It didn't set you in the right light for a decent debate on the subject
Next time, don't join a thread by spouting silly drivel and you may get taken more seriously
I'll say again, as forwards in my opinion, there is very little in it
Rooney is more versatile
----------------------------------------------------------------------
My aim is not to be taken seriously by you two,
------------------------------------
Congratulations
You certainly achieved that objective
Page 8 of 9
6 | 7 | 8 | 9