or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 171 comments are related to an article called:

All Things Tolkien

Page 1 of 7

posted on 6/2/22

Admin, could you please make live
Ta

posted on 6/2/22

First.

posted on 6/2/22



Looks to be a few flashbacks what with the image of the two trees.. I wonder if we'll get a glimpse of Morgoth/Melkor

posted on 6/2/22

Im sure they will show Morgoth in a prologue/ flashbacks

posted on 6/2/22

Im looking forward to seeing in what capacity they show
Celebrimbor
Tom Bombadil
The Witch King

posted on 6/2/22

comment by #If Only, Mithrandir (U22733)
posted 1 hour, 40 minutes ago
Admin, could you please make live
Ta
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Live thread for something 6 months away? Did you turn up a day early to your premature ejaculators support group?

This should be good though looking forward to it. Witch king back story will be interesting, I don’t know much about what they are doing but love LOTR, probably the best trilogy around (sorry star wars).

posted on 6/2/22

Would like to see more of the Moria stuff, dwarfs finding that demon, best part of the first movie was the journey through Moria.

posted on 6/2/22

The books are all you need.

posted on 6/2/22

I had a Ruby Murray yesterday and a few pints of Guinness last night. I had the ring of power earlier

posted on 6/2/22

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 6/2/22

comment by Irishred (U2539)
posted 40 minutes ago
I had a Ruby Murray yesterday and a few pints of Guinness last night. I had the ring of power earlier
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Shall we call you sauron or sore-un?

comment by #4zA (U22472)

posted on 6/2/22

isnt it about Sauron being put in jale n then charming people over time n they let him go n he gose naught agane?

posted on 6/2/22

comment by 4zA - its into the shame and into the guilt and into the fooking fray (U22472)
posted 30 minutes ago
isnt it about Sauron being put in jale n then charming people over time n they let him go n he gose naught agane?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Something like that. He gets captured by the Numenoreans who get deceived by his guise as an elf.

posted on 6/2/22

Comment deleted by Article Creator

posted on 6/2/22

Comment deleted by Article Creator

comment by #4zA (U22472)

posted on 6/2/22

comment by #If Only, Mithrandir (U22733)
posted 6 hours, 22 minutes ago
comment by 4zA - its into the shame and into the guilt and into the fooking fray (U22472)
posted 30 minutes ago
isnt it about Sauron being put in jale n then charming people over time n they let him go n he gose naught agane?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Something like that. He gets captured by the Numenoreans who get deceived by his guise as an elf.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
they mustaben dumb.

they catch n lck up big scary Dark Lord Sauron.

then one morning he puts on a pare of Mr Spock ears n say "Imma Elf now innit" n they fall 4 it.

posted on 10/2/22

Some amazing new shots from Vanity Fair.
Finally we get to see the characters.

Also, 1st trailer due during Super Bowl this Sunday

posted on 14/2/22

New teaser trailor

https://youtu.be/v7v1hIkYH24

posted on 14/2/22

Looking forward to it.

Why are all the comments below the vid in Russian

posted on 14/2/22

Yeh that is weird.
Plenty of bots about

posted on 14/2/22

Ooooh, a LOTR thread..

posted on 14/2/22

I think it looks interesting.

Can anyone tell me why the show is getting backlash? I'm not deep into the tolkien lore but surely they can't have changed much?

posted on 14/2/22

comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 34 minutes ago
I think it looks interesting.

Can anyone tell me why the show is getting backlash? I'm not deep into the tolkien lore but surely they can't have changed much?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Essentially, there is too much creative licence for the Tolkien lore homeboys.

posted on 14/2/22

comment by The Guvnor XI -Iron sharpens Iron- (U12889)
posted 48 minutes ago
I think it looks interesting.

Can anyone tell me why the show is getting backlash? I'm not deep into the tolkien lore but surely they can't have changed much?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not massively into the lore either but the two criticisms I have seen is one elf has short shaved hair when all elves have the opposite, and a female dwarve looks just like a regular human but shrunk when they're supposed to be identical to male dwarves (including beards) but slightly more feminine.

Probably doesn't help that both of those two characters are black, so racists are jumping on the bandwagon.

posted on 14/2/22

I have read some complaining about the ethnicity of one of the elves and personally, It doesn't bother me at all.

Page 1 of 7

Sign in if you want to comment