or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 122321 comments are related to an article called:

Arguing w/strangers cause I'm lonely thread

Page 1457 of 4893

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 17 minutes ago
If you just constantly attack America or Israel, and do not address China or Iran etc too, then eyebrows are raised
-----
Is that what's happening here? Because if it isn't then you're just saying something that's neither here nor there, deviating from the topic so that the discussion cannot focus.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is exactly the goal, blur the lines and detract from/conflate the current events to stop people focusing on a single news story

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 6 minutes ago
You are either for human rights and justice and liberalism and freedom everywhere, or you have a biased agenda and political gripe.
----
What have I said or done that suggests otherwise? If there's nothing and you're just pointing it out then its whataboutery.

If I talk about the states am I then supposed to mention every country In the world afterwards to convince you that I'm not biased?

If I talk about Afghanistan should I always then mention Iran and Iraq and other stans to convince you Im not biased.

Every post on Ja606 should now have headers, footers and footnotes just so people know you're not biased. At this rate no one will ever make a post on here again. You can't cover everything in one post and if you don't then you're biased.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dude, am not aiming stuff at you or just for you or guys here really, I am making an observation after 40 years of how politics and people operate.

And no, mention America and Israel and the Tories all day long, if you wish.

I posted about China and their pollution and right away got cries that per capita, America was worse, from Insert and Dave, so both sides are at it.lol

If I laugh at or query Biden, Trump is brought up.

If I slate SF, unionists get it from posters.

If I post about the EU or remain, the UK and leave are jumped on etc etc..
We all do this and know we do, but at least I admit it, ..😊😊

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Taki Minamino (U20650)
posted 1 minute ago
religion
----------------------------------------------------------------------
God Bless you my san

posted on 6/9/21

If you condemn human rights and govt of Israel,, but fail to call out neighbouring regimes, what is going on
----
Who has done that? If no one then what's the use of saying it. We all know criticism should be as balanced as possible.

If you condemn Palestine without acknowledging Israels flaws, what is going on?

You see, anyone can do whataboutery but people usually have better points to make.

posted on 6/9/21

You are right of course tbab, me and Dave were just covering for our favourite country

China, home of the enslaved Uighurs

OR, you have the agenda, and thinks it's reasonable to compare the pollution of 1.3bn people with 50million

posted on 6/9/21

Dude, am not aiming stuff at you or just for you or guys here really, I am making an observation after 40 years of how politics and people operate.
------
Knowing the right time to make a general observation is a vital debating skill. Facts dropped at the wrong time can totally kill debate and qualify as whataboutery because people wonder "he's right but why now when I'm just raising making my point?"

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 17 minutes ago
If you just constantly attack America or Israel, and do not address China or Iran etc too, then eyebrows are raised
-----
Is that what's happening here? Because if it isn't then you're just saying something that's neither here nor there, deviating from the topic so that the discussion cannot focus.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is exactly the goal, blur the lines and detract from/conflate the current events to stop people focusing on a single news story
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems pretty obvious to me. Basically, they wish you would stop but they can't come out and tell you to shut up so they do the next best thing.

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 9 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 17 minutes ago
If you just constantly attack America or Israel, and do not address China or Iran etc too, then eyebrows are raised
-----
Is that what's happening here? Because if it isn't then you're just saying something that's neither here nor there, deviating from the topic so that the discussion cannot focus.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is exactly the goal, blur the lines and detract from/conflate the current events to stop people focusing on a single news story
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems pretty obvious to me. Basically, they wish you would stop but they can't come out and tell you to shut up so they do the next best thing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok, I have seen Boycott Israel and support for that here and social media, but not the Boycott neighbouring regimes, so why is Israel worse than all other nations, for example?

I have criticised the Israel govt and Hamas,but some pick one side.

I call out Labour and Tory, unionist and nationalist, voted leave, but became more remain, support the UK union, but see merit on Indy views, dislike Trump and Clinton and Biden, so unlike many many here, I ask What About all sides, for balance.

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 26 minutes ago
Dude, am not aiming stuff at you or just for you or guys here really, I am making an observation after 40 years of how politics and people operate.
------
Knowing the right time to make a general observation is a vital debating skill. Facts dropped at the wrong time can totally kill debate and qualify as whataboutery because people wonder "he's right but why now when I'm just raising making my point?"
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Timing, so like my love making, is off.😂😂

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 31 minutes ago
If you condemn human rights and govt of Israel,, but fail to call out neighbouring regimes, what is going on
----
Who has done that? If no one then what's the use of saying it. We all know criticism should be as balanced as possible.

If you condemn Palestine without acknowledging Israels flaws, what is going on?

You see, anyone can do whataboutery but people usually have better points to make.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I call out IDF, oppression of Palestinians, Israel govt and do not ignore the Palestine rights, while also backing Israel's right to exist, Jewish rights in a hostile world, from time began...the oldest hate.

I do not see this as one side good and another bad, unlike some....not aimed at anyone.

posted on 6/9/21

Modern politics, aided by social media and people being angry, has made debate poorer, as we want to crush other opinion now and not compromise or listen.

I can relate to remain voices, republican voices, socialist voices etc, while also seeing alternatives and different angles.

It's boring perhaps, flip floppy, but it's how I am.

I also laugh at myself and my ideas and realise we are just passing through for a short visit, so be nicer to each other while you are here.

Hard to do, and why I stay away from most social media and no longer obsess about news all day, or waste too much time here banging my head off a brick wall.

Peace n out.😂

posted on 6/9/21

I completely disagree with your views on yourself Tbab, I think you lack awareness about your posts and their tone, you don't seek balance at all, you are either right wing, or so contrarian that you never actually show your true views.

Perhaps Instead of trying to enforce your supposed balance, you just engage with the thread using your own views, as others do?

posted on 6/9/21

What's people's views on Geo-engineering, saw a "What if" short on flooding death valley in the USA, to regreen a huge area, open up hydropower opportunities and limit sea level rises.

The offset is that you would be destroying a HUGE area of desert and displacing all of its wildlife, plus the two necessary canals could cost up to £50bn.

posted on 6/9/21

Spent today working on a garden and painting fences for a 91 year old Belfast women, having a great chat in her wee pensioner bungalow, and then on my way to shop saw an old guy lying outside his house, so had to help him up and into his house, and I just went back to check on him, and he is ok.

Two old timers, can hardly walk, but full of beans, humour and chat and humanity, and what life is about for me nowadays...people before politics.

I will leave yeez in peace for a bit.😉😎

Be nice.😊

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 1 hour ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 1 hour, 13 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 21 hours, 47 minutes ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 43 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 1 hour, 36 minutes ago
Been away for 48 hours and return to see that our conversation on current events in the US was derailed as usual

Current events are reasonable to discuss IN ISOLATION, if Texas passes a Draconian law on abortion AND pays people 10k to snitch on their neighbours then that's worth discussing,

We don't need to cover every single nation state to have had such laws in the last 1000 years, nor do we need to list every country that currently has such laws, we were discussing a current news item, stop shutting such conversations down, it's ridiculous.

If America brings in a backwards law I will criticise it, and I'll do the same in isolation if Sweden do it,

If Israel seizes land in Gaza forcibly I WILL discuss it in isolation, and if Norway decides to do the same I'll discuss it.

If the EU makes stupid changes to laws I'll discuss it, and chances are the same people saying "You just hate America" won't pipe up with similar scenarios globally that also need to be added at the bottom as an addendum.

Let people discuss the news ffs, its literally the purpose here.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
And others are free to voice their opinions also Insert. If I want to say x, y and z then I will. I’m not telling anyone that they cannot discuss a,b and c so I don’t see what your problem is. You’re advocating for free speech but trying to deny the same right to others?

Doesn’t make sense mate
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's not like I'm saying "You can't discuss Scandinavia"

But you and Tbab were literally saying "Stop discussing America"

What I'm saying is, that it's ridiculous to weigh in with commentary on current events with shiiiiiit like "Why aren't you criticising Ireland and Scandinavia" when talking about a change of the law in Texas ffs.

Then claiming people have an obsessive hatred of one country because we are talking about the news ffs

----------------------------------------------------------------------
We literally weren’t though, were we? Stop exaggerating and misrepresenting what was said, you’re wasting time in doing so.

The conversation started about the somewhat ridiculous new law. Then it went on to subsiding of the pill etc and it was said that it was ridiculous how a developed country such as the US didn’t offer the pill for free. When actually several other developed countries don’t, including Spain and half of the Scandinavian countries.

It’s fine for people to bemoan the US’s position on free contraceptive pills but it is also fine to point out that several other countries with much more of a socialised outlook and approach also do not offer it for free.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Not quite how the conversation evolved though was it?

The idea that the US should subsidise the pill wasn't pulled out of thin air, it was because I was asserting that banning abortion without offering another alternative was ridiculous, and that if you want to tackle abortion rates then you treat the cause, not just outlaw it with no clauses for Rape and incest.

Nothing at all to do with any other country, unless they too have just announced a six week law, with snoopers bounties.

So yes, it was whataboutery.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It wasn’t whataboutery, people were talking about the US’s lack of free supply of the pill, so I pointed out that several other countries, notably Spain and some of the Scandinavian countries also don’t and they’re very socialised generally, especially with healthcare. Which just shows that it’s not always a predictable picture when it comes to that specific element.

I wasn’t chatting about the ludicrous Texans and I’ve mentioned previously that on this issue this is where I differ from a lot of conservatives, even though it’s obviously a tough topic and not really a clear right or wrong.

I don’t think I responded to a post of yours from memory mate, thought it was someone else.

And as I said, we weren’t literally saying “stop discussing America”.

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 18 minutes ago
What's people's views on Geo-engineering, saw a "What if" short on flooding death valley in the USA, to regreen a huge area, open up hydropower opportunities and limit sea level rises.

The offset is that you would be destroying a HUGE area of desert and displacing all of its wildlife, plus the two necessary canals could cost up to £50bn.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don’t know much about it. Layman it for me

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 49 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 17 minutes ago
If you just constantly attack America or Israel, and do not address China or Iran etc too, then eyebrows are raised
-----
Is that what's happening here? Because if it isn't then you're just saying something that's neither here nor there, deviating from the topic so that the discussion cannot focus.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is exactly the goal, blur the lines and detract from/conflate the current events to stop people focusing on a single news story
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems pretty obvious to me. Basically, they wish you would stop but they can't come out and tell you to shut up so they do the next best thing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Shut up

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 1 hour, 42 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 18 minutes ago
What's people's views on Geo-engineering, saw a "What if" short on flooding death valley in the USA, to regreen a huge area, open up hydropower opportunities and limit sea level rises.

The offset is that you would be destroying a HUGE area of desert and displacing all of its wildlife, plus the two necessary canals could cost up to £50bn.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don’t know much about it. Layman it for me
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a huge subject that covers a broad range of ideas, such as dumping human waste in to the ocean to cause phytoplankton blooms to imitate whales (because we have killed so many) to creating clouds to reflect sunlight back out of the atmosphere.

All come with potential side effects, such as seafood with human gut diseases or chemical rain.

But the flooding deserts one would be a way to manage *where" floods during the early stages of climate change, and the idea of flooding the Sahara has been a topic of conversation for some years, but this is the first time I've seen a proper economic proposal put forward for any of these projects with regards to flooding death valley, population < 300 people, with the potential for homes and businesses and new towns housing 10s if not hundreds of thousands, as well as huge hydroelectric dams, tourism, water sports, and even a new shipping route, as well as it having the potential to be a huge resource with regards to fish.

But deserts also play a role in the climate, most of the earth's breathable air is caused by sea plankton, which would of course exist in these new seas, but the main source of nutrients for them include desert winds blowing dust in to the sea, particularly from the Sahara.

It's gaming and weighing up intervening in natural processes to fight climate change, if flooding some low laying deserts could prevent the need for huge flood defences/relocating cities then that too would be a huge carbon offset.

posted on 6/9/21

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 6/9/21

comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 33 minutes ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 1 hour, 42 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 18 minutes ago
What's people's views on Geo-engineering, saw a "What if" short on flooding death valley in the USA, to regreen a huge area, open up hydropower opportunities and limit sea level rises.

The offset is that you would be destroying a HUGE area of desert and displacing all of its wildlife, plus the two necessary canals could cost up to £50bn.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don’t know much about it. Layman it for me
----------------------------------------------------------------------
It's a huge subject that covers a broad range of ideas, such as dumping human waste in to the ocean to cause phytoplankton blooms to imitate whales (because we have killed so many) to creating clouds to reflect sunlight back out of the atmosphere.

All come with potential side effects, such as seafood with human gut diseases or chemical rain.

But the flooding deserts one would be a way to manage *where" floods during the early stages of climate change, and the idea of flooding the Sahara has been a topic of conversation for some years, but this is the first time I've seen a proper economic proposal put forward for any of these projects with regards to flooding death valley, population < 300 people, with the potential for homes and businesses and new towns housing 10s if not hundreds of thousands, as well as huge hydroelectric dams, tourism, water sports, and even a new shipping route, as well as it having the potential to be a huge resource with regards to fish.

But deserts also play a role in the climate, most of the earth's breathable air is caused by sea plankton, which would of course exist in these new seas, but the main source of nutrients for them include desert winds blowing dust in to the sea, particularly from the Sahara.

It's gaming and weighing up intervening in natural processes to fight climate change, if flooding some low laying deserts could prevent the need for huge flood defences/relocating cities then that too would be a huge carbon offset.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Sounds like balls deep high risk high reward proposals

posted on 7/9/21

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 15 hours, 24 minutes ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 49 minutes ago
comment by Insert random username (U10647)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by Thorgen Kloppinson - I refugee from Guantanamo Bay Dance around the border like I'm Cassius Clay (U1282)
posted 17 minutes ago
If you just constantly attack America or Israel, and do not address China or Iran etc too, then eyebrows are raised
-----
Is that what's happening here? Because if it isn't then you're just saying something that's neither here nor there, deviating from the topic so that the discussion cannot focus.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
This is exactly the goal, blur the lines and detract from/conflate the current events to stop people focusing on a single news story
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Seems pretty obvious to me. Basically, they wish you would stop but they can't come out and tell you to shut up so they do the next best thing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Shut up
----------------------------------------------------------------------

posted on 7/9/21

Happy with Johnson’s changes then?

posted on 7/9/21

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 10 minutes ago
Happy with Johnson’s changes then?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Don't mind admitting I'm fairly dense when it comes to taxation, but on the face of it - it's a good start. Although I'm not sure why they have to create a new tax to plug the gap they've created by cutting other taxes. Presumably, knowing this particularly government, it's some kind of scam on the working people of this country to please the idle wealthy.

comment by Hector (U3606)

posted on 7/9/21

No, why bump up NI and not income tax/capital gains or ?

Conservatives looking after their core vote (the greatest users of social care) at the expense of the young and low paid.

"The Pandemic wasnt part of our manifesto" ffs!

posted on 7/9/21

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

Page 1457 of 4893

Sign in if you want to comment