or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 118 comments are related to an article called:

Saka vs Rashford

Page 4 of 5

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 1 second ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 minutes ago
comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 1 hour, 2 minutes ago
If we don't compare from the same league then you might as well say you'll take andy cook from bradford over rashford or saka. it's silly.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Why is comparing their games silly. They have both played in the same cups as well.

The fairest way, if you wish to make a comparison is goals and assists per minute played.

I doubt there would be very much in it to be honest.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
cos they are cups ..... the randomness of level of opponent should be the obvious outlier to look at here.

are you honestly saying you cant understand the difference?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No where have I said that.

Is Saka’s form in the cups not as good as Rashfords per chance? I know Arsenal had an easier group in the Europey than us. No idea who they played in the other cups. I do recall Oxford being one of them.

As I said above, the fairest way is to compare minutes played.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Im asking you .... can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fari comparison? Saka has played far less cup games than rashford.

Best way to work it out is to directly compare against the same teams and the goals and assists they actually have not what they could do or expect them to do... but what they actually have done

posted on 17/4/23

Im asking you .... can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fari comparison? Saka has played far less cup games than rashford.



That isn’t Rasford’s fault is it? Well it might be because he has been scoring in our cup games to keep us in them where as Saka hasn’t.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 seconds ago
Im asking you .... can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fari comparison? Saka has played far less cup games than rashford.



That isn’t Rasford’s fault is it? Well it might be because he has been scoring in our cup games to keep us in them where as Saka hasn’t.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didnt ask if that was rashfords fault... no on is saying rashford is at fault.

Im asking you:

can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fair comparison? yes or no?

posted on 17/4/23

Oh, and our FA Cup and EFL Cup games have been against Premier League opposition other than Burnley, Reading and Charlton.

So only a couple of crap teams there.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 40 seconds ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 seconds ago
Im asking you .... can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fari comparison? Saka has played far less cup games than rashford.



That isn’t Rasford’s fault is it? Well it might be because he has been scoring in our cup games to keep us in them where as Saka hasn’t.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didnt ask if that was rashfords fault... no on is saying rashford is at fault.

Im asking you:

can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fair comparison? yes or no?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No. Not in the context of this thread. I would want to bring on a player to win me the match that can perform in all competitions, not just one.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
Oh, and our FA Cup and EFL Cup games have been against Premier League opposition other than Burnley, Reading and Charlton.

So only a couple of crap teams there.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah so if you ignore the league 1 team, and the two championship teams then they were against prem teams.

Im no gay if you dont count the 3 guys iv pumped

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 40 seconds ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 seconds ago
Im asking you .... can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fari comparison? Saka has played far less cup games than rashford.



That isn’t Rasford’s fault is it? Well it might be because he has been scoring in our cup games to keep us in them where as Saka hasn’t.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didnt ask if that was rashfords fault... no on is saying rashford is at fault.

Im asking you:

can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fair comparison? yes or no?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No. Not in the context of this thread. I would want to bring on a player to win me the match that can perform in all competitions, not just one.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
you dont get it .... its kl. We are all of differing levels.

If you dont get it then there is no point continuing.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 42 seconds ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
Oh, and our FA Cup and EFL Cup games have been against Premier League opposition other than Burnley, Reading and Charlton.

So only a couple of crap teams there.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah so if you ignore the league 1 team, and the two championship teams then they were against prem teams.

Im no gay if you dont count the 3 guys iv pumped
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I think you are going off tangent their mate.

posted on 17/4/23

No sane manager in the world would chose tap-in bully Rashford over a world class talent like Saka.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 3 minutes ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 40 seconds ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 5 seconds ago
Im asking you .... can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fari comparison? Saka has played far less cup games than rashford.



That isn’t Rasford’s fault is it? Well it might be because he has been scoring in our cup games to keep us in them where as Saka hasn’t.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I didnt ask if that was rashfords fault... no on is saying rashford is at fault.

Im asking you:

can you not see the difference in adding in the cup games and understand why it not a fair comparison? yes or no?
----------------------------------------------------------------------

No. Not in the context of this thread. I would want to bring on a player to win me the match that can perform in all competitions, not just one.


----------------------------------------------------------------------
you dont get it .... its kl. We are all of differing levels.

If you dont get it then there is no point continuing.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

You don’t get what the thread is about and what I am telling you also. Best we agree to disagree.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by HenryKamp (U21315)
posted 3 minutes ago
No sane manager in the world would chose tap-in bully Rashford over a world class talent like Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Daft <surfer->

I don’t think Rashford ever taps them.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 10 seconds ago
comment by HenryKamp (U21315)
posted 3 minutes ago
No sane manager in the world would chose tap-in bully Rashford over a world class talent like Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Daft <surfer->

I don’t think Rashford ever taps them.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Imagine pretending to hold that opinion when we know he has watched Rashford score those 'tap ins' against Arsenal at Old Trafford and the Emirates this season.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by HenryKamp (U21315)
posted 4 minutes ago
No sane manager in the world would chose tap-in bully Rashford over a world class talent like Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What if he wanted someone to score goals?
Surely he’d pick the better goal scorer, if he was sane

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 6 minutes ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 42 seconds ago
comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 2 minutes ago
Oh, and our FA Cup and EFL Cup games have been against Premier League opposition other than Burnley, Reading and Charlton.

So only a couple of crap teams there.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
yeah so if you ignore the league 1 team, and the two championship teams then they were against prem teams.

Im no gay if you dont count the 3 guys iv pumped
----------------------------------------------------------------------

I think you are going off tangent their mate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
tbf you were the one that wanted to bring up the teams in the cups.... if even 1 of them isnt EPL level then they are void surely in terms of comparisons? especially so if one was a league 1 team which he scored 2 in.

The only fair way you could add the cup games in was if both teams played the same opposition in the opposite cups, cos that would then render them equal.

We using stats to compare and if you really want to make the stats comparison fair then it needs to be on a level playing field. but you know doing this leaves Saka looking better. so you will argue anything against it. Im a neutral .. im the one that can call it like it is.

posted on 17/4/23

Rashford this season goal or assist every 96 minutes

Saka this season goal or assist every 138 minutes


So, Rashford for me thanks.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by HenryKamp (U21315)
posted 4 minutes ago
No sane manager in the world would chose tap-in bully Rashford over a world class talent like Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What if he wanted someone to score goals?
Surely he’d pick the better goal scorer, if he was sane
----------------------------------------------------------------------
or the guy who will set a goal up... both equally as important

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 24 seconds ago
Rashford this season goal or assist every 96 minutes

Saka this season goal or assist every 138 minutes


So, Rashford for me thanks.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
is the award they hand out at the end of the season the top goalscorer or the goal per min award?

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Bobby Dazzler (U1449)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by HenryKamp (U21315)
posted 4 minutes ago
No sane manager in the world would chose tap-in bully Rashford over a world class talent like Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
What if he wanted someone to score goals?
Surely he’d pick the better goal scorer, if he was sane
----------------------------------------------------------------------
or the guy who will set a goal up... both equally as important
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Might want to re read what I posted

posted on 17/4/23

Saka, Kane and Rashford at the Euros next summer could be so dangerous. Would be good if we can get Kane as well, would have a year playing with Rashford regularly to develop more chemistry.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 49 seconds ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 24 seconds ago
Rashford this season goal or assist every 96 minutes

Saka this season goal or assist every 138 minutes


So, Rashford for me thanks.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
is the award they hand out at the end of the season the top goalscorer or the goal per min award?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you broken?

I’m answering the question in the OP and seeing as GOALS and ASSISTS you know, help you win games then yeah I’ll choose that as a determining factor.

Wtf are you looking at? Hairstyles?

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 26 seconds ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 49 seconds ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 24 seconds ago
Rashford this season goal or assist every 96 minutes

Saka this season goal or assist every 138 minutes


So, Rashford for me thanks.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
is the award they hand out at the end of the season the top goalscorer or the goal per min award?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you broken?

I’m answering the question in the OP and seeing as GOALS and ASSISTS you know, help you win games then yeah I’ll choose that as a determining factor.

Wtf are you looking at? Hairstyles?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
no im looking at the amount of goals and assists they have totalled in the league and saying saka has been better this year.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by Kobbie The King Mainoo (U10026)
posted 1 minute ago
Saka, Kane and Rashford at the Euros next summer could be so dangerous. Would be good if we can get Kane as well, would have a year playing with Rashford regularly to develop more chemistry.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think in order to have those front three work you need to make sure both Saka and Rashford are almost playing as two strikers running beyond Kane having Kane drop into the false 9 role.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 33 seconds ago
comment by Kobbie The King Mainoo (U10026)
posted 1 minute ago
Saka, Kane and Rashford at the Euros next summer could be so dangerous. Would be good if we can get Kane as well, would have a year playing with Rashford regularly to develop more chemistry.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I think in order to have those front three work you need to make sure both Saka and Rashford are almost playing as two strikers running beyond Kane having Kane drop into the false 9 role.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
so gareth will play mount and sterling instead yea

posted on 17/4/23

Kane often does that for England. Saka’s not quite as adept as running in behind as Rashford, though. Hopefully it’s something he can improve on. We looked our most dangerous, in my opinion, when we had Sterling and Rashford running off Kane a couple of years ago. But due to Rashford and Saka’s form we’ve not seen that much of it.

posted on 17/4/23

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 26 seconds ago
comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 49 seconds ago
comment by Sat Nav (U18243)
posted 24 seconds ago
Rashford this season goal or assist every 96 minutes

Saka this season goal or assist every 138 minutes


So, Rashford for me thanks.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
is the award they hand out at the end of the season the top goalscorer or the goal per min award?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Are you broken?

I’m answering the question in the OP and seeing as GOALS and ASSISTS you know, help you win games then yeah I’ll choose that as a determining factor.

Wtf are you looking at? Hairstyles?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
no im looking at the amount of goals and assists they have totalled in the league and saying saka has been better this year.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well seeing as it’s a one off game and you need form to be the deciding factor you’re going to ignore a load of other games just because they won’t have played the exact same teams?

So if you had an Italian striker and an English striker and your Italian striker had scored a boat load of goals for Italy and your English striker hadn’t scored much if at all for England and this question arises you’re telling me that you’ll just outright ignore the international goals?

Cmon….

Page 4 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment