If we're playing in second tier competitions like the Europa then Rashford.

If against top quality then Saka.

Rashford - cos Saka starts ahead of him everytime...

Rashford. More likely to get you a goal as the stats show.

You could certainly argue that Saka is the better all round player though.

Just don't let either of them take a penalty

13 goals is a measly return for a so called world class player in a thriving team.

Rashford is out there feeding kids and still racked up 28 goals in a badly struggling team

comment by Robbing Hoody - At the end of a storm (U6374)
posted 3 minutes ago
If we're playing in second tier competitions like the Europa then Rashford.

If against top quality then Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Rashford has scored quite a few against Liverpool, hasn't he? So I guess you have a point

Rashford or Ollie Watkins is more accurate. Two purple patch players.

comment by D'Jeezus Mackaroni (U1137)
posted 3 minutes ago
Rashford - cos Saka starts ahead of him everytime...
----------------------------------------------------------------------
good point.

comment by (K̇ash) - Liverpool 7-0 Man U (U1108)
posted 16 seconds ago
Rashford or Ollie Watkins is more accurate. Two purple patch players.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
22, 21 and 28 goals and counting in 3 of the last 4 seasons. Some purple patch.

Rashford slightly more likely to score than Saka.

Saka much more likely to set one up for someone else.

Saka - 12 goals, 10 assists = 22 goal contributions
Rashford - 15 goals , 4 assists = 19 goal contributions.

Arsenal have a quarter of the leagues top 20 scorers, Uniteds 2nd highest is down in 37th

Star boy for me

Greg,

We are not a badly struggling team.

comment by merrysupersteve (relaxed about the situation) (U1132)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Robbing Hoody - At the end of a storm (U6374)
posted 3 minutes ago
If we're playing in second tier competitions like the Europa then Rashford.

If against top quality then Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Rashford has scored quite a few against Liverpool, hasn't he? So I guess you have a point
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah he has a couple, I'm surprised ETH didn't play him in the 7-0 actually.

Will compare their PL numbers:

Saka 12 goals and 10 assists
rashford 15 goals and 4 assist.

Saka edging it.

Yeah he has a couple, I'm surprised ETH didn't play him in the 7-0 actually.

…..

Indeed Hoody. ETH missed a trick there by putting Bruno up against Trent.

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 1 minute ago
Greg,

We are not a badly struggling team.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
We clearly are VC, keep up.

We’re only 3rd in the league having won a cup and are still in the other 2. Clearly struggling.

These comparison articles are rubbish.

comment by Christ We Won (U17162)
posted 3 seconds ago
These comparison articles are rubbish.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
this one is actually decent, two reasonably similar level players, play in similar positions doing similar things.

they do it differently but there is defo comparison to be had.

Saka having the better season as stats will show.

the other telling factor is that Saka is 21 , Rashford 25

Saka, because he has more goal involvements. Just.

comment by Christ We Won (U17162)
posted 6 minutes ago
These comparison articles are rubbish.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
but which one is the worst?

comment by whodunnit (U22710)
posted 2 minutes ago
comment by Christ We Won (U17162)
posted 3 seconds ago
These comparison articles are rubbish.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
this one is actually decent, two reasonably similar level players, play in similar positions doing similar things.

they do it differently but there is defo comparison to be had.

Saka having the better season as stats will show.

the other telling factor is that Saka is 21 , Rashford 25
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I donno I think these articles on this forum never really go anywhere and just descend into rival fans calling each others team and players rubbish, usually. But as of right now I haven't checked out the comments, so maybe I'm wrong on this one

comment by Nickasaurus (U9257)
posted 7 minutes ago
Will compare their PL numbers:

Saka 12 goals and 10 assists
rashford 15 goals and 4 assist.

Saka edging it.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

What are their overall numbers? As it wouldn’t be limited to the Premiership in this context.

comment by Robbing Hoody - At the end of a storm (U6374)
posted 7 minutes ago
comment by merrysupersteve (relaxed about the situation) (U1132)
posted 4 minutes ago
comment by Robbing Hoody - At the end of a storm (U6374)
posted 3 minutes ago
If we're playing in second tier competitions like the Europa then Rashford.

If against top quality then Saka.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Rashford has scored quite a few against Liverpool, hasn't he? So I guess you have a point
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Yeah he has a couple, I'm surprised ETH didn't play him in the 7-0 actually.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
But he scored at Old Trafford against Liverpool, right? And he scored against Arsenal home and away (total 3 goals in those games). And he scored against City.