or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 122 comments are related to an article called:

Who?

Page 2 of 5

posted on 1/11/12

Wenger clearly didn't want to sell him. I swear you guys must think Wenger is re tarded. Why on earth would he sell his best player to Man Utd?

posted on 1/11/12

"...had RVP up front vs Sunderland, Stoke and Chelsea we would have at least 5 more points."


Speculation. You know how wasteful RVP could be too. If you are watching the old videos where Cesc provided so many goal scoring opportunities for our strikers and we wasted the most you might agree that we miss him.

posted on 1/11/12

Well RVP single handedly got us into the top 4 last season. Are you telling me if we had RVP we would've lost the games against Schalke and Norwich. As much as it pains us all to say RVP is a world class player and any team would miss him. Look how much he has improved man united already.

posted on 1/11/12

"Wenger clearly didn't want to sell him. I swear you guys must think Wenger is re tarded. Why on earth would he sell his best player to Man Utd?"

So why did he sell him then? Apparently RVP wanted to stay as well.

posted on 1/11/12

You don't know that.

RVP missed bags of sitter last season, how do you know he would've scored the chances Giroud had?
_______________________________

Why Kamran? You are too quick for me. Had the same idea.

comment by 8bit (U2653)

posted on 1/11/12

Giroud is starting to look good he'll be scoring for fun soon.

posted on 1/11/12

"RVP missed bags of sitter last season, how do you know he would've scored the chances Giroud had?"

RVP is twice the player Giroud is at the moment. He would no doubt bury most of those chances.

posted on 1/11/12

We were garbage vs Schalke and Norwich, don't think RVP would have made a difference. It is the games vs Stoke, Sunderland and Chelsea when we missed him

posted on 1/11/12

"Well RVP single handedly got us into the top 4 last season. Are you telling me if we had RVP we would've lost the games against Schalke and Norwich. As much as it pains us all to say RVP is a world class player and any team would miss him. Look how much he has improved man united already."
===

No, he did not single-handedly get us into the top 4. that's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. He was our player of the season and played brilliantly, but he was helped out majorly by the players around him.

He wouldn't have done anything against Norwich or Schalke because we created fack all in those games.

posted on 1/11/12

Dubbed, want to know your opinion. Cesc or the ?

posted on 1/11/12

"RVP is twice the player Giroud is at the moment. He would no doubt bury most of those chances."
===

I'm not saying RVP is not better than Giroud. I'm saying he also misses plenty of chances and we don't know if he would've scored the chances Giroud had.

comment by Tu Meke (U3732)

posted on 1/11/12

We're missing both players.

But we missed Cesc far more than we're missing RvP atm.

posted on 1/11/12

"So why did he sell him then? Apparently RVP wanted to stay as well."
===

Obviously because of the board...

posted on 1/11/12

gunnerthru
Without Cesc. We still haven't recovered from him. We played beautiful football cause of him.
He single handedly dominated teams.

posted on 1/11/12

Definitely Cesc. No doubt.

posted on 1/11/12

thanks Dubbed.

posted on 1/11/12

No, he did not single-handedly get us into the top 4. that's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. He was our player of the season and played brilliantly, but he was helped out majorly by the players around him.

He wouldn't have done anything against Norwich or Schalke because we created fack all in those games.

RVP scored 30 league goals last season, where would we have finished without him? RVP won many games last season with moments of magic e.g Everton at home Liverpool away. RVP is a special player and if we had him this season we would've had more points than we have at the moment. For anyone to say we dont miss RVP is just stupid.

posted on 1/11/12

I know how many goals RVP scored for us last season, I didn't start following football two months ago. He did score a few special goals for us, but he also scored a lot of taps in and easy goals. Not taking anything away from him but everything we done was around him.

I don't think we're missing him.

posted on 1/11/12

We would be competing for the title if RVP was still here so we clearly miss him!!!

comment by Tu Meke (U3732)

posted on 1/11/12

Come on Kamran, I usually agree with what you say, but we are definitely missing the . Nowhere near as much as Cesc, but the feeling is there.

posted on 1/11/12

Again Batmanu, we don't know that ffs!

comment by 8bit (U2653)

posted on 1/11/12

obviously we'd be better with him but we don't miss him in the sense that we'll score pretty much the same if not more goals as a team.

posted on 1/11/12

exactly 8bit.

posted on 1/11/12

@Youareverminated

Fact is we won feck nothing with the . Fact is that we without him wouldnt have played for a CL League place. There is no doubt.

Fact is also that with all the goals the scored for us last season we almost manage to mess it up if Fulop hadnt put in a horror show.

posted on 1/11/12

8bit is programmed to agree with Kamran, even though the muppet's wrong.
Two garbage posters slurping each other off.

Page 2 of 5

Sign in if you want to comment