or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 234 comments are related to an article called:

We look about as good as the Ramos era

Page 10 of 10

posted on 16/11/12

TCW,

You've got the wrong end of the stick mate. My point was, if Harry declared he wanted to leave, then this would be a reason he "had to go".

It was just an addition to all the other comments i have made.

Your opinion is that, even though none of us know the reason, it was an out & out blatant reason for doing so. This doesnt make sense.

posted on 16/11/12

Your opinion is that, even though none of us know the reason, it was an out & out blatant reason for doing so. This doesnt make sense.

----

No, just that there could have been, so to say unless he wanted to go there was no good reason is flawed.

TBH I think we're caught on a little boring semantic loop

posted on 16/11/12

TCW,

I didnt say there wasn't a good reason. I'm just saying that no-one knows the reason. So how can you (or anyone) say it was a good reason, if you dont know what it was?

As i say, it doesnt make sense.

posted on 16/11/12

How can one say that it definitely isn't? I only said it MAY be.

posted on 16/11/12

TCW,

I only said it MAY be

============

Again, exactly my point.

Which takes me back to the sentence i said earlier:

"Definitely & maybe are 2 completely separate words, its just a coincidence they both form the title of one of my favourite albums of all time".

posted on 16/11/12

Indeed. You wanted maybe and went with definitely. Stubborn or no this is undeniable

posted on 17/11/12

We're Spurs & have only achieved a 4th placed finish twice in Premiership history - and both times under just one manager.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Chicken

Harry had to go for two reasons.

Firstly he started believing his own press and secondly, and more importantly, he started thinking he was bigger and more important than the club

posted on 17/11/12

grandspurs

I'm not sure i believe any of those reasons, neither do i think they are sufficient reasons for him to go or the official line for his sacking. They certainly are not reasons he "definitely" had to go in my book.

posted on 18/11/12

They would be good enough for me if I were chairman

Page 10 of 10

Sign in if you want to comment