or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 424 comments are related to an article called:

Most Overrated Eleven Ever

Page 3 of 17

posted on 7/7/15

Beckham lovers

posted on 7/7/15

But is anyone claiming Zola is better than any of them?

Zola is always fondly remembered because he was one of the first big names to come to the PL and do really well and is one of Chelsea's best players simply because they don't really have the history clubs like United or Liverpool have.

posted on 7/7/15

comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 4 minutes ago
Valencia is overrated. Everyone thinks he's sh-t, he's worse than that.
----------------------------------------------------------------------


Comment of the day

posted on 7/7/15

comment by Marcelino- #SilvioForFIFAPresident (U6171)
posted 23 seconds ago
David Beckham wasn't overrated, people just underrated him because they thought he put more attention into his celebrity status than his football career.

That's a valid point, but very few people can cross a ball like Beckham.
----------------------------------------------------------------------

The reason I mention it is that he rarely gets a mention from our fans these days.

posted on 7/7/15

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 7/7/15

Becks had 'Grinta' which was more than any other England player of the last 20 years has had

comment by wump (U5046)

posted on 7/7/15

Is this article serious?

posted on 7/7/15

Ledley King is the most overrated player on the list, I'd say.

At least every other player listed has been brilliant in their own right, despite being overrated, but King was no more than an average prem defender who was occasionally brilliant but never achieved anything to warrant the praise he got.

He had a good Euros and stood out as the only above average defender in a terrible Spurs team, and somehow he's the most talented cb England have had and only injuries stopped him reaching legendary status.

posted on 7/7/15

comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 24 seconds ago
But is anyone claiming Zola is better than any of them?

Zola is always fondly remembered because he was one of the first big names to come to the PL and do really well and is one of Chelsea's best players simply because they don't really have the history clubs like United or Liverpool have.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That would be a fair comment if Zola was remembered strictly as a Chelsea legend given that they don't have very many, but he is bracketed as one of the best ever and in my opinion given he isn't even the best Italian forward of his era then it doesn't stack up.

posted on 7/7/15

Beckham underrated ive heard it all now. When he played people would go on and on about him. People dont really remember or rate him now coz he was never really that good

posted on 7/7/15

comment by #4zA (U19575)
posted 7 minutes ago
one I dont agree with is Robert Pires, as I have never even heard of him
----------------------------------------------------------------------
droll

posted on 7/7/15

No, it's another dig at 'coward' Mourinho.

Zola was easily better than Pippo and Chiesa.

posted on 7/7/15

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 7/7/15

Darren

Was he massively praised though? I though the reputation he got was that he was a good reader of the game and because of his f-cked up knees did very well to last as long as he did.

Didn't Henry once say he was the hardest defender to play against? Maybe that increased his reputation?

posted on 7/7/15

comment by Giant Machine-5 hite 4 brains. (U20563)
posted 3 seconds ago
No, it's another dig at 'coward' Mourinho.

Zola was easily better than Pippo and Chiesa.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Agree and was on par with most of the others. Was great at parma too

posted on 7/7/15

comment by Mad Mex (U6687)
posted 3 minutes ago
Totti
Del Piero
Baggio
Chiesa
Vieri

All superior to Zola in the 90's

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Thought you were doing another overrated list for a minute

posted on 7/7/15

I'd agree King is definitely the most overrated on the list.

All the other players HAVE BEEN GOOD PLAYERS at points in their career- but they were also overrated.

I feel people are attacking my team because they have poor English skills and can't tell the difference between a good player and an overrated player.

Cristiano Ronaldo is overrated if people tell me he's better than Messi- as that's a rating too high for him.

Capiche?

posted on 7/7/15

I honestly don't ever recall Zola being labelled 'one of the best ever'.

People just like him a bit more than normal because he looks a bit like a leprechaun.

posted on 7/7/15

Zola-Brolin-Tino.

That was great wasn't it 4za?

posted on 7/7/15

1982, depends who you listen to I suppose. But his career very much mirrors Wes Brown's, though not as good, but Wes Brown isn't considered among the very best cb's to play in the prem whereas many consider King to be.

posted on 7/7/15

Zola was a good player- and ultimately his great personality also makes people remember him fondly- but the truth was there were not only far superior forwards in his era, but also superior Italian forwards. That therefore diminishes his status as among the Premier League's greatest.

posted on 7/7/15

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 7/7/15

comment by Marcelino- #SilvioForFIFAPresident (U6171)
posted 24 seconds ago
I'd agree King is definitely the most overrated on the list.

All the other players HAVE BEEN GOOD PLAYERS at points in their career- but they were also overrated.

I feel people are attacking my team because they have poor English skills and can't tell the difference between a good player and an overrated player.

Cristiano Ronaldo is overrated if people tell me he's better than Messi- as that's a rating too high for him.

Capiche?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
How can all time greats like cafu zidane be overrated you foool. If that is your definition then all players are overrated esp D Beckham

posted on 7/7/15

comment by manutd1982 (U6633)
posted 21 seconds ago
I honestly don't ever recall Zola being labelled 'one of the best ever'.

People just like him a bit more than normal because he looks a bit like a leprechaun.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Always reminded me of "nik nak" from James bond

posted on 7/7/15

Brown didn't have his knee problems though did he? I remember reading King's were so bad he never trained with his team mates but just watched training and swam. That's pretty impressive.

Page 3 of 17

Sign in if you want to comment