or to join or start a new Discussion

Articles/all comments
These 763 comments are related to an article called:

Automatic or Manual cars?

Page 18 of 31

posted on 13/3/14

manuals, you get more of a buzz out of them
automatics are slower to pick up in speed

------
Not anymore, as the ones with gear shift paddles allow far far quicker gear shifts.

I find myself driving in "manual mode" anyway with these.

posted on 13/3/14

comment by Redinthehead - At least we didnt finish 13th! (U1860)
posted 31 seconds ago
manuals, you get more of a buzz out of them
automatics are slower to pick up in speed

------
Not anymore, as the ones with gear shift paddles allow far far quicker gear shifts.

I find myself driving in "manual mode" anyway with these.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
so, basically you prefer a manual then?

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 13/3/14

I guess I just don't understand this "inconvenience" of having to change gears.

Hippo, you make it sound like a labourious task that pi55es you off. I don't even think about it, it's just something I do.

posted on 13/3/14

I know Conor.

posted on 13/3/14

so, basically you prefer a manual then?

-------
..more of can't break the manual habit of thinking I know better!

posted on 13/3/14

Comment deleted by Site Moderator

posted on 13/3/14

comment by Hippo on Toast (mufc) - follow the new ja606 twitter @jalob_official (U1301)
posted 6 seconds ago

in a manual i put my foot down, then take my foot off the gas, put my foot on the clutch, change gears, put my foot back on the gas, the accelerate for a bit, then do it all again.

--------------------------------

this makes it sound laborious. In reality it takes about half a second and comes naturally to anyone driving for longer than about 3 months.

posted on 13/3/14

comment by conormcgrace (U4307) posted 21 minutes ago
Knew it would happen.

To be honest, the only information of worth I actually garnered from this thread was that, between the ages if 16 and 38, VC regularly spilt his drink whilst driving.
--------------------------

posted on 13/3/14

comment by Hippo on Toast (mufc) - follow the new ja606 twitter @jalob_official (U1301)
posted 54 seconds ago
well it's a question of taste i guess
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well said, I think we can all agree on that. Try telling VC...

posted on 13/3/14

you stil need to use your feet and your hand to control the wheel

Mr C

That explains the eratic driving in the UK, then.

posted on 13/3/14

VC you know what I mean

posted on 13/3/14

comment by 2014 - Year of the Januzaj (U18323)
posted 28 seconds ago
comment by conormcgrace (U4307) posted 21 minutes ago
Knew it would happen.

To be honest, the only information of worth I actually garnered from this thread was that, between the ages if 16 and 38, VC regularly spilt his drink whilst driving.
--------------------------


----------------------------------------------------------------------

that did make me actually laugh out loud too

posted on 13/3/14

comment by Robert pan Versie #20 (U1145)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Hippo on Toast (mufc) - follow the new ja606 twitter @jalob_official (U1301)
posted 54 seconds ago
well it's a question of taste i guess
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well said, I think we can all agree on that. Try telling VC...

.............

I haven't argued against anyones taste. In fact I did say each tio their own earlier.

I have just argued which is easier to drive.

The clue is in the word, automatic.

posted on 13/3/14

comment by Vidicschin (U3584)
posted 13 seconds ago
comment by Robert pan Versie #20 (U1145)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by Hippo on Toast (mufc) - follow the new ja606 twitter @jalob_official (U1301)
posted 54 seconds ago
well it's a question of taste i guess
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Well said, I think we can all agree on that. Try telling VC...

.............

I haven't argued against anyones taste. In fact I did say each tio their own earlier.

I have just argued which is easier to drive.

The clue is in the word, automatic.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Fair do's. In that case we are all in agreement that some prefer manual and some automatic

Hope Arab has managed to make his decision.

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 13/3/14

And VC, no one has denied that automatics are easier, just that the ease doesn't outweigh the benefits of manuals (which is a matter of opinion).

It was only really your coffee analogy that got people arguing.

comment by T-BAD (U11806)

posted on 13/3/14

My grandma got an automatic cos as she slowed down with old age she found trying to do a few things at once in a manual a bit too much, much like VC.

Its obvious that automatics are easier to drive and one day I'll no doubt end up owning one and loving it, but right now I enjoy driving and I can't imagine enjoying it if I was in an auto, I think I'd find it really dull.

comment by tmd16 (U4307)

posted on 13/3/14

Anyway, home time for me after a day of doing naff all thanks to this thread.

posted on 13/3/14

My grandma got an automatic cos as she slowed down with old age she found trying to do a few things at once in a manual a bit too much, much like VC.

.................

I think you are confusing 'to much' with unnessesary.

Maybe your granny is on to something that you might figure out once you get older.

posted on 13/3/14

Don't think I've ever had a thread reach so many comments without it being a match thread, was a good discussion point regardless.

posted on 13/3/14

Hope you learned something Arab

See you all later

comment by T-BAD (U11806)

posted on 13/3/14

Well yeah its unnecessary nowadays, but she admits doing it all confused her which is why she prefers the auto as she only has to concentrate on one thing.

I don't doubt one day I'll come around to your way of thinking but for now I wouldn't wanna

posted on 13/3/14

would have thaught it was a no brainer to prefer autos over manual.

posted on 13/3/14

comment by blabla (U11635) posted 1 minute ago
would have thaught it was a no brainer to prefer autos over manual.
------------------------
Did you happen to have a hard time trying to learn how to drive a manual?

posted on 13/3/14

comment by blabla (U11635)
posted 1 minute ago
would have thaught it was a no brainer to prefer autos over manual.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
back to square one...

posted on 13/3/14

arab

The lesson to be learn't here was that if you are bone idle, don't want to spill your coffee/ beer or whatever and want to do the minimum amount involved in driving, then go auto.

On the other hand if want to do far more than is required, constantly have to stop start, resulting in spilled liquids, unnessesary hand and foot movement then drive a gear stick.

Page 18 of 31

Sign in if you want to comment