Entirely predictable accolades from a Man U 'fan', intended to more raise emotions than generate reasonable debate.
What are you on about? If you don't agree with my list then fair enough, but your comment is pretty ludicrous.
Liverpool ST holder in my office is delighted that Gerrard is leaving. His exact words: "Good, he's cráp. Rodgers bottled it keeping him on this season.."
Personally thought it a bit harsh.
comment by 5 years to go.. (U20035)
posted 1 minute ago
Entirely predictable accolades from a Man U 'fan', intended to more raise emotions than generate reasonable debate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You need to seek professional help to battle your persecution complex.
The OP's stance on Gerrard seems logical to anyone without a proverbial rod up their behinds.
Wumming or not, IMO, Gerrard is a PL legend. Maligned by many - and by God, he has his limitations- but at his peak was a bonafide world class player.
Your mate is an idiot and if he met Gerrard would be creaming himself.
Anyway I'd have him top because I can. As for the rest of the list I don't really agree with Robson being in there. You could give Barry a shout over him tbh just for the shere amount of games he's played whilst also being a massive player for Villa but also winning stuff with City. Could Toure and Silva be in there now? Silva is arguably City's greatest ever player.
Not sure what Fabregas has done to get in the list or Alonso for that matter.
Either way wish Stevie all the best.
Yaya Toure has to be there comfortably top 10
Robbing, I can't agree with Barry ever being mentioned on a par with Robson...
I did consider putting Toure in there, but Essien edged it for me.
As for Silva, he definitely warrants a place on some list, but I didn't want to get into the minefield of having to include the likes of Hazard and other "number 10s" so stuck with more traditional CM - easier to compare a Gerrard to a Keane.
Do you think Gerrard will join Lampard at New York and they'll finally prove that they can indeed play together?
comment by The_Red_Cognoscente (U9741)
posted 56 seconds ago
comment by 5 years to go.. (U20035)
posted 1 minute ago
Entirely predictable accolades from a Man U 'fan', intended to more raise emotions than generate reasonable debate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You need to seek professional help to battle your persecution complex.
The OP's stance on Gerrard seems logical to anyone without a proverbial rod up their behinds.
Wumming or not, IMO, Gerrard is a PL legend. Maligned by many - and by God, he has his limitations- but at his peak was a bonafide world class player.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No persecution complex at all, what a strange comment to make... just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones. For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
How can Igor Biscan be left out? Disgraceful.
just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones.
-
difficult time?
judgemental overtones?
Seek help.
For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
^If we only ever discussed the last game then Gerrard would end his career on a par with David Batty.
comment by Aggers Right Giftbow (U3402)
posted 49 seconds ago
How can Igor Biscan be left out? Disgraceful.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
With great difficulty, believe me. Toiled over that one for... a sufficient and justifiable amount of time..
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 1 minute ago
Robbing, I can't agree with Barry ever being mentioned on a par with Robson...
I did consider putting Toure in there, but Essien edged it for me.
As for Silva, he definitely warrants a place on some list, but I didn't want to get into the minefield of having to include the likes of Hazard and other "number 10s" so stuck with more traditional CM - easier to compare a Gerrard to a Keane.
Do you think Gerrard will join Lampard at New York and they'll finally prove that they can indeed play together?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He won't go to prove he can play with Lampard though he'll go for £££££££'s and/or a challenge. I think he will go to America although somewhere like Celtic or an Italian club wouldn't surprise me.
Agree on Silva, you have chosen CM's in all, so it makes sense to me. Opinions are like bottoms - everyone has one!
cant believe that Ince isnt in that top ten
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 0 seconds ago
just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones.
-
difficult time?
judgemental overtones?
Seek help.
For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
^If we only ever discussed the last game then Gerrard would end his career on a par with David Batty.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That was too easy. Veneer slipped and within minutes.
I rest my case.
Dunno about you Robbing, but a comfortable retirement in New York with all my millions has far more appeal to me than Glasgow - no offence Scotland.
comment by 5 years to go.. (U20035)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 0 seconds ago
just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones.
-
difficult time?
judgemental overtones?
Seek help.
For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
^If we only ever discussed the last game then Gerrard would end his career on a par with David Batty.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That was too easy. Veneer slipped and within minutes.
I rest my case.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No, you proved nothing.
I simply used that as an example to show what a clown you're being.
No wonder you're a "first time poster, long time reader."
Gerrard and Scholes would be top for me. Also I would have Keane higher than Viera.
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 7 seconds ago
Dunno about you Robbing, but a comfortable retirement in New York with all my millions has far more appeal to me than Glasgow - no offence Scotland.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I know what you mean but I also reckon that someone like Gerrard may find it hard looking to Bradley Wright Phillips as a star player. The quality is still fairly poor I reckon. If I were him I'd go to Italy - not like he's going to meet LFC in the CL!!
comment by RBW - The future is Orange (U2335)
posted 3 minutes ago
cant believe that Ince isnt in that top ten
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Really? Or is this another Biscan comment?
Ince was quality, but I don't see who he would displace in my list. He'd be floating around 10th if I were to place him based on my memories of him, but I think i'd include Yaya over him.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Good point about BWP, robbing (and the quality in general).
I guess it depends on his mentality doesn't it. His desire for a challenge or a paycheck. Could easily see him waltzing into either Milan team to be fair.
On a side note, I think Henderson will make a quality captain. I think it'll give him the boost he needs to impose himself on games with more regularity. You look much better when he's more influential on the game. I was a massive Hendophobe when you first signed him, but the ladt 18 months have proven me wrong. I think he's quality - with Coutinho, Sterling, Lallana and Sturridge ahead of him he could be devastating.
No idea why Rodgers put him at RB to shoehorn in Gerrard after his performance against Swansea.
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
Ince is in with a shout for sure.
-
But... he... went to Liverpool....
I tried to keep my list unbiased...
BUT HE WENT TO LIVERPOOL!
What would your top 5/10 be Robbing? Would Ince be in there?
He has been a fantastic servant for us but purely on footballing ability he is not as good as Alonso, Molby, Whelan, Gary Mc to name a few.
He will / desire to win and do well for our club is second to none.
He has squeezed every ounce of ability he has and performed 99% of the time for us but his recipe is work rate, agression, passion, etc.
Gerrard was a great player for Liverpool. Top 10 midfielders in the prem? No chance. He was not even good enough to play in midfield for Liverpool ahead of Alonso and Mascherano
Sign in if you want to comment
Gerrard's Standing in the game
Page 1 of 28
6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10
posted on 2/1/15
Entirely predictable accolades from a Man U 'fan', intended to more raise emotions than generate reasonable debate.
posted on 2/1/15
What are you on about? If you don't agree with my list then fair enough, but your comment is pretty ludicrous.
Liverpool ST holder in my office is delighted that Gerrard is leaving. His exact words: "Good, he's cráp. Rodgers bottled it keeping him on this season.."
Personally thought it a bit harsh.
posted on 2/1/15
comment by 5 years to go.. (U20035)
posted 1 minute ago
Entirely predictable accolades from a Man U 'fan', intended to more raise emotions than generate reasonable debate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You need to seek professional help to battle your persecution complex.
The OP's stance on Gerrard seems logical to anyone without a proverbial rod up their behinds.
Wumming or not, IMO, Gerrard is a PL legend. Maligned by many - and by God, he has his limitations- but at his peak was a bonafide world class player.
posted on 2/1/15
Your mate is an idiot and if he met Gerrard would be creaming himself.
Anyway I'd have him top because I can. As for the rest of the list I don't really agree with Robson being in there. You could give Barry a shout over him tbh just for the shere amount of games he's played whilst also being a massive player for Villa but also winning stuff with City. Could Toure and Silva be in there now? Silva is arguably City's greatest ever player.
Not sure what Fabregas has done to get in the list or Alonso for that matter.
Either way wish Stevie all the best.
posted on 2/1/15
Yaya Toure has to be there comfortably top 10
posted on 2/1/15
Robbing, I can't agree with Barry ever being mentioned on a par with Robson...
I did consider putting Toure in there, but Essien edged it for me.
As for Silva, he definitely warrants a place on some list, but I didn't want to get into the minefield of having to include the likes of Hazard and other "number 10s" so stuck with more traditional CM - easier to compare a Gerrard to a Keane.
Do you think Gerrard will join Lampard at New York and they'll finally prove that they can indeed play together?
posted on 2/1/15
comment by The_Red_Cognoscente (U9741)
posted 56 seconds ago
comment by 5 years to go.. (U20035)
posted 1 minute ago
Entirely predictable accolades from a Man U 'fan', intended to more raise emotions than generate reasonable debate.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
You need to seek professional help to battle your persecution complex.
The OP's stance on Gerrard seems logical to anyone without a proverbial rod up their behinds.
Wumming or not, IMO, Gerrard is a PL legend. Maligned by many - and by God, he has his limitations- but at his peak was a bonafide world class player.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No persecution complex at all, what a strange comment to make... just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones. For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
posted on 2/1/15
How can Igor Biscan be left out? Disgraceful.
posted on 2/1/15
just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones.
-
difficult time?
judgemental overtones?
Seek help.
For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
^If we only ever discussed the last game then Gerrard would end his career on a par with David Batty.
posted on 2/1/15
comment by Aggers Right Giftbow (U3402)
posted 49 seconds ago
How can Igor Biscan be left out? Disgraceful.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
With great difficulty, believe me. Toiled over that one for... a sufficient and justifiable amount of time..
posted on 2/1/15
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 1 minute ago
Robbing, I can't agree with Barry ever being mentioned on a par with Robson...
I did consider putting Toure in there, but Essien edged it for me.
As for Silva, he definitely warrants a place on some list, but I didn't want to get into the minefield of having to include the likes of Hazard and other "number 10s" so stuck with more traditional CM - easier to compare a Gerrard to a Keane.
Do you think Gerrard will join Lampard at New York and they'll finally prove that they can indeed play together?
----------------------------------------------------------------------
He won't go to prove he can play with Lampard though he'll go for £££££££'s and/or a challenge. I think he will go to America although somewhere like Celtic or an Italian club wouldn't surprise me.
Agree on Silva, you have chosen CM's in all, so it makes sense to me. Opinions are like bottoms - everyone has one!
posted on 2/1/15
cant believe that Ince isnt in that top ten
posted on 2/1/15
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 0 seconds ago
just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones.
-
difficult time?
judgemental overtones?
Seek help.
For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
^If we only ever discussed the last game then Gerrard would end his career on a par with David Batty.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That was too easy. Veneer slipped and within minutes.
I rest my case.
posted on 2/1/15
Dunno about you Robbing, but a comfortable retirement in New York with all my millions has far more appeal to me than Glasgow - no offence Scotland.
posted on 2/1/15
comment by 5 years to go.. (U20035)
posted 1 minute ago
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 0 seconds ago
just don't need fans from other teams purporting to be sharing in this difficult time with judgemental overtones.
-
difficult time?
judgemental overtones?
Seek help.
For you time would be best spent doing the analysis of your most recent game, no.?
^If we only ever discussed the last game then Gerrard would end his career on a par with David Batty.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
That was too easy. Veneer slipped and within minutes.
I rest my case.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
No, you proved nothing.
I simply used that as an example to show what a clown you're being.
No wonder you're a "first time poster, long time reader."
posted on 2/1/15
Gerrard and Scholes would be top for me. Also I would have Keane higher than Viera.
posted on 2/1/15
comment by 🔥💩He's French, He's Flash... I'm sorreh teh say it's Moyseh... (U9335)
posted 7 seconds ago
Dunno about you Robbing, but a comfortable retirement in New York with all my millions has far more appeal to me than Glasgow - no offence Scotland.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
I know what you mean but I also reckon that someone like Gerrard may find it hard looking to Bradley Wright Phillips as a star player. The quality is still fairly poor I reckon. If I were him I'd go to Italy - not like he's going to meet LFC in the CL!!
posted on 2/1/15
comment by RBW - The future is Orange (U2335)
posted 3 minutes ago
cant believe that Ince isnt in that top ten
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Really? Or is this another Biscan comment?
Ince was quality, but I don't see who he would displace in my list. He'd be floating around 10th if I were to place him based on my memories of him, but I think i'd include Yaya over him.
posted on 2/1/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/1/15
Good point about BWP, robbing (and the quality in general).
I guess it depends on his mentality doesn't it. His desire for a challenge or a paycheck. Could easily see him waltzing into either Milan team to be fair.
On a side note, I think Henderson will make a quality captain. I think it'll give him the boost he needs to impose himself on games with more regularity. You look much better when he's more influential on the game. I was a massive Hendophobe when you first signed him, but the ladt 18 months have proven me wrong. I think he's quality - with Coutinho, Sterling, Lallana and Sturridge ahead of him he could be devastating.
No idea why Rodgers put him at RB to shoehorn in Gerrard after his performance against Swansea.
posted on 2/1/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/1/15
Comment deleted by Site Moderator
posted on 2/1/15
Ince is in with a shout for sure.
-
But... he... went to Liverpool....
I tried to keep my list unbiased...
BUT HE WENT TO LIVERPOOL!
What would your top 5/10 be Robbing? Would Ince be in there?
posted on 2/1/15
He has been a fantastic servant for us but purely on footballing ability he is not as good as Alonso, Molby, Whelan, Gary Mc to name a few.
He will / desire to win and do well for our club is second to none.
He has squeezed every ounce of ability he has and performed 99% of the time for us but his recipe is work rate, agression, passion, etc.
posted on 2/1/15
Gerrard was a great player for Liverpool. Top 10 midfielders in the prem? No chance. He was not even good enough to play in midfield for Liverpool ahead of Alonso and Mascherano
Page 1 of 28
6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10